Contingency Recruiting

What is contingency recruiting?

Contingency recruiting is a type of recruitment service where recruiters are paid a fee only if they successfully place a candidate in a job position.

In this method, the contingency recruiting agency typically takes on the risk of the search process. They invest time and resources in finding suitable candidates without any guarantee of payment unless one of their candidates is hired. This can make contingency recruiters highly motivated to fill positions quickly and efficiently.

Contingency recruiting is popular for filling mid-level positions and roles where the urgency or volume of hires is high. This allows companies to engage multiple recruiters simultaneously without initial costs, increasing the chances of finding suitable candidates.

How does contingency recruiting work?

Here is a breakdown of how contingency recruiting generally works:

• Step 1: Client needs assessment: The process begins when a company (client) identifies a vacancy and contacts a contingency recruiting firm to fill the position. The recruiter meets with the company to understand the requirements, responsibilities, and qualifications needed for the role, as well as the company culture and values.
• Step 2: Candidate search: The recruiter then searches for suitable candidates for the position. This search may involve looking through the recruiter’s existing database of candidates, posting job ads, networking, and headhunting.
• Step 3: Screening and selection: Candidates are screened to ensure they meet the qualifications and experience required by the employer. This may include reviewing resumes, conducting interviews, and assessing candidates’ skills.
• Step 4: Candidate presentation: The recruiter presents the most suitable candidates to the employer, often providing a shortlist from which the employer can choose.
• Step 5: Job offer and acceptance: If the employer decides to hire one of the candidates, they will make a job offer. If the candidate accepts, then the recruiter has successfully filled the position.
• Step 6: Payment of the fee: Upon the successful placement of a candidate, the recruiter receives a fee. This fee is usually a percentage of the candidate’s first year’s salary and is agreed upon in the initial contract between the employer and the recruiter.

HR tip

Maintain clear communication when engaging either retained or contingency recruiters. Focus on regular updates on the evolving job requirements, feedback on presented candidates, and alignment of hiring timelines for a smoother, more effective hiring process.

Contingency recruiting benefits and limitations

Advantages

• No upfront costs: Employers pay only when a candidate is successfully placed, making it a financially low-risk option. This can be particularly advantageous for smaller companies or those with tight budgets.
• Speed and efficiency: The pressure to succeed means that contingency recruiters may work faster to fill positions than internal HR departments, which can be beneficial for roles that need to be filled urgently.
• Access to a wider talent pool: Contingency recruiters often maintain extensive networks and have access to a large pool of candidates. They work to fill many positions across various companies, so they continuously engage with a broad spectrum of talent.
• Specialization and expertise: Many contingency recruiters specialize in specific industries or functional areas, bringing in-depth knowledge and a nuanced understanding of the roles they are tasked to fill. This expertise can lead to better matches and more effective placements.

Disadvantages

• No quality guarantee: Because contingency recruiters are paid upon placement, there is a potential risk that they may prioritize speed over thoroughness, possibly leading to a less rigorous vetting process. 
• High fees: Although there is no upfront cost, the fees upon successful placement are typically a significant percentage of the candidate’s annual salary. This can be costly, especially for high-salary positions.
• Candidate ownership issues: There can be disputes over candidate ownership, especially if multiple agencies present the same candidate. This can lead to conflicts and complications in the hiring process.
• Less personalized attention: Contingency recruiters often work on multiple positions for various clients simultaneously. This can lead to a less personalized approach than retained recruiters, who typically offer each client more dedicated attention and services.

What is the difference between retained and contingency recruiting?

Retained and contingency recruiting differ primarily in their fee structure and the nature of the relationship between the recruiter and the client. Here is a more detailed overview: 

Choosing between the two:

• For critical, high-impact roles: Companies might prefer retained recruiting due to the detailed approach and the assurance of a recruiter’s full attention and resources.
• For standard or urgent hires: Contingency recruiting can be effective due to its no upfront cost model and the speed with which multiple recruiters might bring suitable candidates.

FAQ